BankConductIndex

Issues ›

Card dispute or chargeback

Chargeback and Section 75 claims about goods or services not received or not as described.

10,051banking decisions on this issue
22.8%upheld where an outcome is recorded
35firms with 20+ decisions here

Rules the ombudsman applied

Derived from the rules actually cited in these decisions, ranked by how often they appear — not from an editorial view of which rules matter.

Consumer Credit Act 1974 · cited in 4,634

Consumer credit rights, including Section 75 joint liability for card purchases.

Read the instrument

Payment Services Regulations 2017 · cited in 337

Governs how payment firms must handle authorised and unauthorised payments, including liability for unauthorised transactions.

Read the instrument

FCA DISP (Dispute Resolution) · cited in 215

How firms must handle complaints and how the Ombudsman decides them.

Read the instrument

FCA Consumer Duty (PRIN 2A) · cited in 122

Requires firms to deliver good outcomes for retail customers.

Read the instrument

CRM Code (APP scam reimbursement) · cited in 70

Voluntary code on reimbursing victims of authorised push payment scams, superseded for in-scope payments by the PSR requirement.

Read the instrument

Equality Act 2010 · cited in 40

Duties toward customers with protected characteristics, including reasonable adjustments.

Read the instrument

Which firms lose on this

FirmDecisionsUpheldUphold rate
Bank of Scotland Plc4506314.0%
Santander UK Plc43710223.3%
Barclays Bank UK PLC4307216.7%
Lloyds Bank PLC4045413.4%
Nationwide Building Society3708523.0%
Barclays Bank Plc3365014.9%
American Express Services Europe Limited3257924.3%
Tesco Personal Finance Limited32313842.7%
HSBC UK Bank Plc2777727.8%
National Westminster Bank Plc2612810.7%
NewDay Ltd2309340.4%
MONZO BANK LIMITED1984924.7%
Revolut Limited1813318.2%
MBNA Limited1772313.0%
Clydesdale Bank Plc1564528.8%
HSBC Bank plc1523523.0%
TSB Bank plc1253225.6%
PayPal Europe Sarl & Cie, SCA1215343.8%
Starling Bank Limited991616.2%
Sainsbury's Bank Plc993232.3%
Capital One (Europe) plc922021.7%
Vanquis Bank Limited781417.9%
MARKS AND SPENCER FINANCIAL SERVICES PLC621219.4%
Halifax Limited61914.8%
WorldPay (UK) Limited5747.0%
Metro Bank PLC561933.9%
NATIONAL WESTMINSTER BANK PUBLIC LIMITED COMPANY49714.3%
PayPal Sarl & Cie, SCA461021.7%
John Lewis Financial Services Limited431637.2%
Virgin Money plc431841.9%
Bank of Ireland (UK) Plc36719.4%
PayPal UK Ltd34926.5%
J.P. Morgan Europe Limited3339.1%
Creation Financial Services Limited32928.1%
Wise Payments Limited2528.0%

Firms with fewer than 20 decisions on this issue are excluded — the rate would not mean anything.

In the ombudsman’s words

Mr G complained about a transaction for £299.99 on his credit card account
— decision DRN9995811, Santander UK Plc
Mr B complains that Nationwide Building Society (“Nationwide”) have rejected his claim for compensation under section 75 Consumer Credit Act (1974) (“s75”).
— decision DRN9994576, Nationwide Building Society
Miss R complains that Marks & Spencer Financial Services Plc wrongly rejected her claim for a refund under section 75 of the Consumer Credit Act.
— decision DRN9992851, Service. She
Mr C complains that Santander UK Plc gave him incorrect information when he disputed a transaction on his credit card account.
— decision DRN9989480, Santander UK Plc

Quotes are shown only where the exact wording was verified against the decision text.

The US counterpart

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) runs a separate complaint database for American consumers. We map its issue labels onto this issue ourselves — the CFPB does not — and the two datasets are not comparable: UK figures above are ombudsman decisions with an adjudicated outcome, while these are complaints made to a US regulator, most of which are never adjudicated. A count of one is not a count of the other, so no rate, percentage or ratio is calculated between them.

The CFPB recorded 13,344 complaints mapped to this issue, received between July 2021 and August 2023, across all US consumer financial products.

Most common CFPB issue labels within this mapping:

Problem with a purchase shown on your statement — 13,344 complaints

Source: CFPB Consumer Complaint Database, not scoped to banking — the CFPB’s complaint categories span all consumer financial products, not just banking.